(& scroll down to read my literary sleuthing posts)
Thanks! -- Arnie Perlstein, Portland, OR

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Just ONE more thing about the Pride & Prejudice subtext of Letter 82......

I knew in the back of my mind that I had left out something significant when I sent my last post about the Pride & Prejudice subtext of Letter 81, but I just couldn't tease it out of my mind, until _now_--it just came to me, so here it is, I think you'll agree it was worth the effort to bring it to awareness:

I recalled having recently posted the following Wikipedia passage as part of my response to Anielka's discovery of the veiled allusion to Cranmer's Articles in Mr. Rushworth's speeches in Mansfield Park:

"This was done following the queen’s _excommunication_ by the Pope in 1570. That act destroyed any hope of reconciliation with Rome and it was no longer necessary to fear that Article XXIX would offend Catholic sensibilities."

If you've read my last post, you know exactly why that passage is so exciting in relation to Letter 81, because in that last post, I argued that Lady Catherine de Burgh threatens to in effect _excommunicate_ Elizabeth Bennet---in order, among other things, to avoid pollution of the shades of Pemberley.

So, now I suggest to you that the attempted (but, it should be noted, totally unsuccessful) excommunication of _Elizabeth_ Bennet by "Pope Lady Catherine the One and Only" is, in part, a veiled allusion to the _historical_ excommunication of Queen _Elizabeth_ I of England by the Pope in 1570. And....this adds yet further meat to the veiled allusion to "Bell, book, and candle" in Letter 81!

What does it mean? A great deal, although it will take a while to think it all the way through. But for now I can say first that we know that Queen Elizabeth I was the centerpiece of the youthful Jane Austen's History of England--and, per Annette Upfal's brilliant sleuthing out of the Austen girls's veiled family history, a representation of the witch-like Mrs. Austen---so, in a funny way, we've come back to Diana's post about "Bell Book and Candle"---when we put together (1) JA and CEA collectively, in both word and image, portraying their mother as a kind of regal witch, with (2) JA portraying the attempted excommunication of a "bewitching" Elizabeth who becomes "Queen" of Pemberley, with (3) JA in Letter 81 joking about all of this in code, and also connecting the dots to their friend Elizabeth Bigg, it's clear that this was a Big Deal in the mind of Jane Austen on a variety of levels, in both the overt and the shadow story of P&P, and with regard to the religious and historical subtext of the novel as well. fits perfectly with _other_ material I've previously excavated but _never_ made public to date.

At this point, I am hesitant to say I am done with Letter 81, because I would not at all be surprised if more aspects of this veiled allusion pop up during my routine followup procedures with discoveries like this. Somehow this one seems ripe for further excavation.

Cheers, ARNIE
@JaneAustenCode on Twitter

No comments: